[Latest News][6]

2016
Achievers
Advisory
Agriculture
Albay
Albay News
Announcements
Banner
Bicol
Bicol Express
bicol local news
bicol local newspaper
Bicol News
bicol news latest
Bicol Songs
Bicol Vigilantes
Bicolana beauties
Bicolano achievers
Bikol news
Binibining Pilipinas
Business
Camarines Norte
Camarines Sur
Caramoan Massacre
Case in Point
Catanduanes
Celebrations
Church
Column
Community
Contributions
Culture
Daet
Daraga
Development
Disaster
Documents
Drugs
Economy
Editorial
Education
Entertainment
Environment
Events
Feature
Features
Filipino News
Food
Food Trip
Government
Headlines
Health
Human Interest
Infographics
Infrastructure
Iriga
Iriga City
Isipon Osipon
Jobs
Jokes
Kantang suanoy
Legazpi
Legazpi City
Letters
Libmanan
Lifestyle
Ligao City
Live
Masbate
masbate city
mayon
MayonPH
Media
Mining
Modelo Bikolano
Nabua
Naga
Naga City
Nagueno
Nation
National
News
News Bullets
OFW
Opinion
Oragon
Orgullo
Palarong Bicol 2014
Palarong Bicol 2015
Penafrancia
Penafrancia 2014
Photos
Places
PNR
Police
Police Report
Politics
Polls
Power
Power Watch
Rawitdawit
Region
Science
Sorosgon
Sorsogon
Sorsogon City
Sorsoson
Special
Sports
Tabaco City
Tigsik
Tips
Tourism
Trending
Trivia
Videos
virac
Weather
Weekly Roundup
Who reads Bicol Standard
Willy Bayola
World
Youth

Court of Appeals junks Bernaldez petition

BATO, Camarines Sur —The 12th Division of the Court of Appeals has dismissed the Petition for Certiorari and Prohibition filed by petitioner Jeanette O.R. Bernaldez, municipal mayor here questioning the Joint Resolution dated January 28, 2015 of Assistant Ombudsman Jennifer Jardin-Manalili in OMB-L-C-10-07-11-J, for violation of Section of Sectioin 3 (e) of RA No. 3019, and OMB-L-A-10-0685-J, for Oppression, Abuse of Authority and Violation of RA No. 6713, criminal and administrative cases, respectively.

Right: Mayor Jeanette Bernaldez Left: Court of Appeals
Photos by Bato MPS, CA
The said resolution of the Ombudsman imposed a 6-month and one day suspension against Bernaldez without pay.

The CA said that the petition filed by Bernaldez deserves an outright dismissal for being premature.

“Although petitioner Bernaldez filed a Motion for Reconsideration of the Joint Resolution, there is no indication that the same has been resolved by the office of the Ombudsman,” the CA said.

“Time and again, jurisprudence dictates that the filing of a motion for reconsideration is required before resort to the extraordinary remedy of certiorari to afford the court or quasi-judicial body which rendered the assailed order to correct a mistake committed by inadvertence,” the CA added.

Moreover, if there is any order issued by the Office of the Ombudsman resolving petitioner’s motion for reconsideration, the original or certified true copy of the said order was not attached to the Petition. Likewise, sorely missing is the date of the receipt of the order or resolution denying petitioner’s Motion for Reconsideration, which is a material allegation that must be stated in the Petition pursuant to Section 3 of Rule 46, of the Rules of Court. Absent such material statement, the timeliness of the filing of the instant Petition cannot be precisely determined, the decision said.

Meanwhile, the CA also stated that even if the procedural lapses were brushed aside, it cannot take cognizance over the Petition for lack of jurisdiction.

The Joint Resolution rendered by the Office of the Ombudsman is an adjudication of both the criminal and administrative charges against Bernaldez.

The Ombudsman Act does not provide the remedy of appeal from the decisions of the Ombudsman in criminal or non-administrative cases, as its jurisdiction if only limited over administrative disciplinary case.

It will be recalled that despite receipt of the suspension order imposed by the Ombudsman thru the Department of Interior and Local Government (DILG) Regional Director Elouisa T. Pastor, and Provincial Director Arnel Renato L. Madrideo, Bernaldez continuously defied said order.

Bernaldez remained in her office as she contended that she was still waiting for the resolution of this petition pending with the CA.

As this developed, Acting Mayor Alvin Sacueza told the media that he instructed the Philippine National Police (PNP) of this town to enforce the decision of the Ombudsman, especially regarding the presence of some of Bernaldez’ who still occupy the Office of the Mayor.

Sacueza said that the local PNP has until July 16 to comply with the order. Otherwise, he will be compelled to request for the immediate relief of the local PNP.

Meanwhile, Barnaldez’ supporters said the beleaguered mayor will raise the latest order issued by the Court of Appeals to the Supreme Court.



The signatories in the CA decision were Associate Justices Zenaida T. Galapate- Laguelles, Mariflor P. Punzalan Castillo asnd Florito S. Macalino of the 12th Divison of the CA.—BICOLSTANDARD.COM

Bicol Standard

Bicol news

Start typing and press Enter to search